Moonsighting vs Calculation — The Debate Continues…

Moonsighting vs Calculation — The Debate Continues…

The foundation of Islamic law is rooted in ease, universality, and accessibility—not in complexity, technicality, or scientific exclusivity. Islam is a religion meant for all people across cultures, levels of education, and geographies. Its laws are designed to be practical and implementable so that every Muslim can fulfill their religious obligations with clarity and confidence.

This principle of simplicity is reflected in the Prophet Muhammad’s ﷺ guidance on determining the beginning of lunar months, particularly Ramadhan and Eid:

“Fast when you see it (the new moon), and break your fast when you see it. If it is cloudy, then complete Sha‘ban as thirty days.” (Sahih Bukhari; Sahih Muslim)

“We are an unlettered nation; we neither write nor calculate. The month is like this and this,” (showing 29 or 30 days with his fingers) (Sahih Bukhari; Sahih Muslim)

The debate over calculation gained new momentum with the rise of precise astronomical science and the global dispersion of Muslim communities. This issue reflects a deeper dynamic between tradition and modernity, text and science, and the need for both precision and unity. While differing opinions remain—and may continue for the foreseeable future—they all stem from a shared devotion to honoring the sacred times established by Allah. In navigating these differences, it is important that we act with taqwa, approaching the matter with sincerity, humility, and mutual respect, always seeking to preserve the unity and integrity of the Ummah.

Share this post

Facebook
X
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Search
Categories

Related Entries

We Don't Deserve Anything
Narrated `Aisha:Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) said, “Do good deeds properly, sincerely, and moderately...
Read More
6
Achieving Success
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم  The Quran emphasizes purification to achieve success in this world and the...
Read More
Iqra’: Reclaiming the Lost Art of Reading
Reading a book is one of the most powerful habits we can reclaim in our fast-paced, screen-filled lives. ...
Read More
Let’s Read Surah Kahf Today (Friday)--Faith & Reliance on Allah
The story of the Youth of the Cave in Surah Al-Kahf is a powerful testament to faith and reliance on...
Read More